Manual vs. Electric Security Shutters: The Real Ontario Debate

scroll down

If you’ve ever thought about security shutters for your home or cottage, you’ve run smack into this question:
Manual or electric?

Sure, it’s a first-world problem, but it’s also an Ontario problem. Why? Because winter. Because power outages. Because convenience.

Let’s settle this once and for all.

Manual Shutters: Old School Reliability

Manual shutters are just what they sound like—a hand-operated crank, or sometimes a strap pull. They’re simple, rugged, and don’t rely on electricity.

Pros:

  • Reliable during power outages (hello recent Ontario ice storm)
  • Less expensive to install
  • Simple mechanism, less can go wrong
  • Decades-long lifespan

Cons:

  • Manual labour (obviously)
  • Hard to operate if mounted high or large
  • Less convenient if used frequently

Electric Shutters: Welcome to Easy Street

Push-button operation, remote controls, or even app-based smart-home integration. Electric shutters are as easy as pointing at your window and pressing a button.

Pros:

  • Ultimate convenience—perfect for frequent use
  • Can integrate with home automation systems
  • Great for large windows or second-story installs
  • Impresses your neighbours and in-laws

Cons:

  • More expensive upfront
  • Depend on power (though battery backups exist)
  • More components, so higher chance of repairs eventually

Ontario Winters: The Real Test

Manual shutters don’t care if there’s a storm. You crank, they move. But electric shutters? If your power is out and you don’t have a backup, they stay put.

But let’s be real:

  • How often is your power actually out long enough to matter? (Okay, maybe twice last winter.)
  • Do you really want to crank shutters when it’s -30°C?

Cost Comparison: Let’s Talk Numbers

Shutter TypeAverage Installed Cost (Ontario)
Manual Shutters$900–$1,500 per window
Electric Shutters$1250–$2,500+ per window

Bottom line: Electric costs more, but you’re paying for ease and automation.

🛠️ Maintenance & Repairs: Keep It Simple or Go High-Tech?

  • Manual: Virtually zero maintenance. Lubricate occasionally. Repairs rare and easy.
  • Electric: Motors, switches, remotes, sensors—more moving parts, more potential problems. But quality systems last years without trouble.

Who Should Go Manual?

Choose manual if you:

  • Want ultimate reliability in all conditions
  • Are installing on a cottage that’s often vacant
  • Prefer simple, rugged, no-fuss solutions
  • Don’t mind doing some work yourself

⚡ Who Should Go Electric?

Go electric if you:

  • Love convenience and tech
  • Have multiple or large shutters
  • Want smart-home integration
  • Will use them daily or weekly
  • Hate manual cranks as much as mosquitoes

Final Verdict: What Ontario Homeowners Choose Most

Most Ontario homeowners with cottages go manual—simple and worry-free.
Urban/suburban homes? Mostly electric—convenient and modern.

The smartest move?
Assess your own priorities: cost, convenience, and your feelings about manually wrestling shutters at -20°C.

Still unsure? We’re always happy to talk specifics.

Need better security? Explore shutters now

Related Posts

    Related Posts