10 Cottage Horror Stories You Won’t See on HGTV (But Definitely Happen)

scroll down

Ah, HGTV.
Where cottages smell like cinnamon, everyone wears freshly pressed linen, and a raccoon has definitely never kicked in the back window.

Real life?
A little spicier.

Here’s what you’re actually signing up for north of Barrie:


1. “The Great Patio Screen Door Massacre of 2022”

Lake Muskoka.
One nice afternoon.
One rogue wind gust.

Next thing you know, your patio screen door is:

  • Off its track
  • Flapping in the breeze like a sad surrender flag
  • Floating across the neighbor’s lawn

And you’re Googling “how much for patio screen door repair” with a shaky hand.


2. “The Squirrel Mafia Moves In”

You think you own the cottage?
You don’t.
The squirrels do.

By the time you notice them:

  • They’ve paid zero rent
  • They’re throwing acorn raves in your attic
  • They’ve chewed the wires so badly you can only watch 2 channels: static and more static

Somewhere between Bala Falls and Bracebridge, this is someone’s reality today.


3. “The Bear Who Loved Trail Mix (Too Much)”

Lesson learned the hard way near Bass Lake:

  • Rule #1: Never leave snacks near a window.
  • Rule #2: Security screens exist for a reason.
  • Rule #3: Bears do not politely knock.

One bag of trail mix =
One destroyed window =
One bear now telling all his buddies where the good stuff is.


4. “Kayak Launch Fail: The TikTok Tragedy”

Filmed somewhere suspiciously close to Gravenhurst:

  • Teens tried to launch a kayak through a patio door “for content.”
  • Door lost. Kayak lost. Dignity lost.
  • Likes on TikTok: 2,317.

Net result:
Zero working screens.
One sad dad driving to Home Hardware.


5. “Windstorm: 1, Patio Umbrella: 0”

Wasaga Beach, August.
Forecast says “breezy.”

You leave your patio umbrella up “just for a few more minutes.”

Next thing you know, it’s:

  • Sailing majestically over Tiny Marsh
  • Ripping through the patio screen
  • Taking your mosquito netting and your will to live with it

Congratulations. You now own a $200 canvas kite.


6. “Muskoka Seagulls: The Airborne Menace”

Here’s something you don’t see on Property Brothers: Lakeside Edition:
Seagulls dive-bombing your open cottage windows like it’s Pearl Harbor.

One woman near Moon River swears a gull dropped a dead fish into her living room.
Screen was torn.
Dog was traumatized.
Grandma almost passed out.

Muskoka: not for the weak.


7. “Chipmunk Takeover: Tiny But Mighty”

Don’t let their size fool you.
Chipmunks are the Navy SEALS of cottage invasions.

One tiny hole in your screen =

  • Full pantry raid
  • Couch cushions ripped open for “nesting materials”
  • A 1-in-3 chance you’ll find one inside your bed

True story from just outside Port Severn.
She still can’t sleep without checking the pillows first.


8. “The DIY Dock Disaster”

Somewhere near Sparrow Lake, a guy tried to “fix” his dock with duct tape, zip ties, and “positive vibes.”

Result:

  • Dock floated away during a windstorm.
  • Patio screen door ripped clean off by a loose canoe.
  • Neighbor’s dog got a free ride to Beaverton.

Moral of the story: if it needs duct tape and a prayer, it probably also needs Security Screens.


9. “Mice in the Walls: Home Edition”

They say you should worry about black bears.

Wrong.

You should worry about tiny cottage mice setting up a cozy Airbnb inside your walls by Thanksgiving.

One couple near Severn Falls heard “scratching” at night.
Turned out:

  • Mice had built an entire mouse city.
  • Including food storage, “washroom” zones, and presumably a Gravenhurst Centennial Squeak & Swim rec centre.
  • Ripped through the window screens for easy access, like it was their private portal.

10. “The Epic Bat Extraction of 2021”

Victoria Harbour.
Peaceful evening.
Fireplace lit.
Wine poured.

Suddenly:
BAT. IN. THE. HOUSE.

Flapping, screeching, total mayhem.
Dad swinging a pool net like an Olympic fencer.
Mom shrieking something about rabies and inheritance rights.

Guess how it got in?
Ripped screen left unrepaired.

(Happy ending: nobody died. Bat still at large.)


So What’s the Lesson Here?

Sure, you can laugh now (and you should).
But when you’re up north…

🛡️ Strong screens = fewer kayak crashes through your patio door.
🛡️ Tight window seals = fewer bears tasting your trail mix.
🛡️ Roller repairs = fewer spontaneous umbrella flights into Lake Simcoe.

Skip the horror show.
Contact WindowRises and let’s armor up your cottage screens properly before this summer becomes a new campfire story.

    Related Posts